aboutsummaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/externals/gridflow/TODO
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
authorN.N. <matju@users.sourceforge.net>2008-07-08 05:56:10 +0000
committerN.N. <matju@users.sourceforge.net>2008-07-08 05:56:10 +0000
commit089475041fe26964d72cb2ebc3559a36ba89a2f2 (patch)
tree4ea7537e82b2ee34748ef7cbfc18c523425d4f7a /externals/gridflow/TODO
parentd1ad56f1da41e7a88eb9a52d6b0daaf145b54ea7 (diff)
trying to import gridflow 0.9.4
svn path=/trunk/; revision=10148
Diffstat (limited to 'externals/gridflow/TODO')
-rw-r--r--externals/gridflow/TODO431
1 files changed, 431 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/externals/gridflow/TODO b/externals/gridflow/TODO
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..c6a1818a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/externals/gridflow/TODO
@@ -0,0 +1,431 @@
+/* $Id: TODO 3975 2008-07-04 19:57:32Z matju $ */
+
+0.9.5
+[ ] get rid of architecture.html
+[ ] support "get" in abstractions
+[ ] fix [nbx]<->[hsl] relationship in [#camera]
+[ ] bugs roman
+[ ] add claude's fixes
+[ ] other gf mails in inbox
+[ ] #line_to_polygon is buggy
+[ ] #draw_polygon init_lines() not sufficiently called
+[ ] regular dc1394 options
+[ ] irregular dc1394 options: white_shading, white_balance
+ trigger_mode? trigger, trigger_delay
+[ ] Accumulation of Background Statistics
+[x] correction/détection de translations dans l'image (avec fft et #remap_image).
+[ ] cvEstimateRigidTransform
+[ ] compenser pour les ajustements progressifs ou soudains de luminosite
+[x] ajouter detection et correction d'interference par fft
+[ ] cvEllipse
+[ ] cvApproxPoly pour un seul poly `a la fois
+[ ] cvMeanShift (?)
+[ ] cvCamShift (?)
+ Ça s'utilise presque comme MeanShift, sauf que ça requiert un autre type non-grid.
+ Celui-ci peut être représenté comme une grid de 5 éléments pour faire plus facile
+ (contrairement à cvHistogram, qui contient une grid ND mais a besoin de quelques fields de plus que ça).
+[ ] cvCalcBackProject (?)
+[ ] cvCalcHist, cvCreateHist.
+[ ] on doit aussi commencer à rajouter des types non-grid. Le premier sera CvHistogram et est requis pour tous les objets dont le nom contient "Hist".
+[ ] SnakeImage (what is the concept of 'energy', squared luminosity?)
+ J'aurais supposé que oui, mais c'est juste trois mesures reliées à trois forces qui "shapent" la courbe:
+ espacement égal des points, réduction des angles, et correspondance avec l'image même (qui doit normalement
+ être un edge-detect d'une image plus vieille).
+[ ] cvOpticalFlow
+
+whatever version
+[ ] [cv.split]
+[ ] reestablish 'gzfile' feature in a better way. (gzfile is disabled for now)
+[ ] ...
+[ ] [fps]: translate into pd: "publish if fps>0.001" (to remove outliers)
+[ ] conversion from float to int is inconsistent: when to round and when to trunc?
+[ ] reimplement negative indices in [listelement] and [listsublist]
+[ ] with pwc, 720x480 crashes
+[ ] fix SDL modifiers
+[ ] fix quoting in [display]
+
+soon:
+ * remove reference.*ml
+ * videodev.c should be upgraded to V4L2 asap.
+
++-------+-------+-------+-------+-------+-------+-------+-------
+Common Video Framework :
+
+[ ] a common library for all video IO (cameras, files, web), which is the
+ project of Thomas H and Johannes.
+
+[ ] a six-way converter for GEM/PDP/GridFlow. There are already
+ converters between GEM and PDP and between GEM and GridFlow but
+ there is none between PDP and GridFlow and then some things could
+ be easier to install and run in a cross-platform way.
+
+[ ] a way to make GEM/PDP/GF conversions *implicitly* instead of
+ having objects for that.
+
+[ ] threads for video?
+[ ] GEM geos vs 3DP: how do they compare?
+[ ] is there anything else deserving to be unified between the video plugins?
+[ ] videojack
+[ ] http://gstreamer.freedesktop.org/
+[ ] distinguish between C++ types Grid* and GridFlow*
+[ ] make [#draw_points] [#draw_rect] [#edit_polygon]
+[ ] Salsaman recommends supporting Videojack because of unicap support which means getting DV support for free.
+[ ] look at camorama
+[ ] OpenCV
+[ ] Generic Image Library: http://opensource.adobe.com/gil/html/giltutorial.html
+[ ] [for] has a bug in "from".
+[ ] #out x11 doesn't accept 0-sized grids
+[ ] #print doesn't accept 0-sized grids
+[ ] #inner doesnt support seeds of size>1, and isn't vecop-compatible, and ...
+[ ] #inner could optimise permutation matrices?
+ClaudiusMaximus matju: [#draw_image] inlet 0 method "op <opname>" is undocumented, but very useful :)
+ClaudiusMaximus matju: [unix_time] is maldocumented, outlet 0 is a grid Dim[28](uint8), not a symbol
+
+[ ] update doc
+[ ] claude wants http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_scan
+
+malloc alignment = 4 mod 8 (en utilisant valgrind)
+
+ClaudiusMaximus matju: feature request: [#store4], behaves like store but accepts grids
+of floats as coordinates and interpolate using 4-point interpolation, eg, right inlet ->
+(3 3 f # 0 0 0 1 1 1 2 4 8), left inlet -> (1 # 0.5) outputs (0.5 0.5 0.5)
+(or whatever the interpolation would really be), left inlet (2 # 1.5 1.5) outputs (3)
+
+http://oprofile.sourceforge.net/about/
+also: qprofile, amd profiler, opreport -cl --demangle=smart
+
+[ ] -ftree-vectorizer-verbose
+[ ] try removing or modifying -falign on PPC/OSX
+[ ] encoding of quicktime RGBA only works with [#cast b] (is that still true?)
+[ ] reading tux.tga is completely broken
+[ ] install of libquicktime is very wrong on my system (is it 0.9.8?)
+[ ] make example on separable convkernels
+[ ] add concepts of hot inlet and conf inlet at the code level
+[ ] [display] should use clocks to update tk less often
+[ ] [display] leaks in server ?
+[ ] deprecation warnings
+[ ] Add a video latency patch (in examples)
+[ ] Numop: warn on misalignment
+[ ] remove GridInlet* ?
+[ ] configure chokes if GCC3 doesn't have the C++ plugin
+[ ] [#import~]
+[ ] [#export~]
+[ ] [#expr]
+[ ] [#line]? [#pipe]? [#delay]?
+[ ] #: option swap
+[ ] consider including [mysql] [renamefile] [ls] [shell]
+[ ] re-enable int64,float64
+[ ] added #matrix_solve, #slice
+[ ] Copy-on-Write (COW)
+[ ] internals documentation
+[ ] internal grid protocol redesigned
+[ ] raise limit of in/outlets from 10 to 100 or unlimited.
+[ ] look into -ftree-vectorize
+[ ] look at Tetra Piccolo capture cards, as well as ImpactVCB (Hauppauge)
+
+[145] "list -1"->[@import] only tells error message once every other time
+[144] small leak remaining in x11. may have to do with non-use of XDestroyImage.
+[140] is [@convolve] actually cross-convolution?
+ that is, convolves with a mirror image of the convolution matrix.
+[139] [peephole]
+ <mis> matju: if you try to move the GOPed abstraction the peepholes don't move along
+ <mis> he :) better yet, the abstraction's bounding box's lower right corner will not
+ move up or to the left of the low right corner of the peephole it contains.
+ Instead it will resize itself as you move it around.
+[134] #import with zero size crashes?
+[133] numop ** can freeze GF
+[117] osx: [#store] crash instead of raising
+[107] MMX computations may be done misaligned, which may be bad.
+[105] when file not found, mpeg error messages are wrong, they say the filename is "".
+[102] osx: error: shmget failed (cannot allocate memory) in X11, for regular pictures
+[078] "unsupported codec" bogus errors.
+[025] format_grid: write test for other bpv's
+[030] FormatGrid: not properly tested (crashes sometimes)
+[031] stdout should be redirected if bridge is present
+[034] format/mpeg3.c,quicktime.c might cause lockup on exit
+[038] some seeds aren't typechecked
+[039] jpeg file cat crashes on second file (jpeglib buffering?)
+[040] GRID_FINISH triggered while backstore ???
+[079] can trap segfaults in codecs of libquicktime.
+[090] http://poynton.com/notes/colour_and_gamma/ColorFAQ.html#RTFToC30
+[041] what would be a way to make GF work well with Pd's idea of a list?
+[045] write unit tests about required functionality
+[046] write unit tests about error checking
+[047] make system to ensure everything is working before a release.
+[048] potential issues between fork() and X11 ?
+[054] it's possible to crash by sending data in two inlets of a same object at once
+
+--- make the development process more test-driven:
+ * file every feature request and bug report into base/test.rb so
+ that gridflow fails those tests THEN make gridflow pass those tests.
+
+===================
+
+Installation
+[ ] less compile-time checks and more run-time checks
+[ ] should GridFlow be bundled with some of its own dependencies?
+[ ] find a good profiler (not gridflow's internal...)
+[ ] cross-compile:
+ http://www.libsdl.org/extras/win32/cross/
+ http://rooster.stanford.edu/~ben/linux/cross.php
+
+Documentation
+[ ] make a short feature list as a promo
+[ ] add credits
+[ ] document how to report bugs, basic troubleshooting
+[ ] document our distribution of the archives
+[ ] ascii conventions: [foo] vs "foo", etc.
+[ ] document internals
+[ ] describe indexmap in doc
+[ ] document backward compatibility issues
+[ ] architecture: class->type/shape->use->role
+[ ] heavily hyperlink documentation
+[ ] automate more parts of the documentation
+[ ] benchmarks (especially: simple video i/o)
+[ ] mimic [pdp_help_input] [pdp_help_output]: they are convenient
+--- remember to keep doc/help/screenshots/examples up to date
+
+Architecture
+[0.9] reentrancy of objects (to allow true recursion)
+[0.9] inlet-attrs (attrs associated to inlets)
+[ ] eliminate the Dim class, replacing by Grid itself (?).
+[ ] pull mode (functional-style)
+[ ] bidirectional messages (constraint/relational-style)
+[ ] send-reply messages (imperative-style)
+[ ] add reflection (#global:classes, #global:methods, ...)
+[ ] transmitting grids by diffs?
+[ ] dispatch on _#{i}_-named methods (any selector one inlet)
+[0.9] generalize the backstore
+[ ] Outlet#buffer should harmonise with the lcm of its corresponding Inlet#factor's.
+[ ] lazy grids: Grid#operator T* makes sure all the grid is received
+ and Grid#range(int start, int n, T bogus) makes sure the
+ specified part of the grid is received.
+[0.9] accounting: grids messages packets numbers bytes copybytes
+[0.9] memory profiling
+[ ] add a "query" class for debugging other objects?
+ (would be able to extract extra info from each object/class)
+[ ] add a GridFlow::LaterException or something
+ (which tells to retry later with the same packet because another
+ grid reception is not completed yet.)
+[ ] interpret nested lists as n-dimensional.
+[0.9] MMX memcpy() ?
+[0.9] MMX _runtime_ autodetection
+
+Computation Objects
+[ ] #counter (similar to #for)
+[ ] #for "step" argument should have default {1...}
+[ ] zero option in #convolve (?)
+[ ] #conv (simpler #convolve) should allow n-D convolution
+[ ] #convolve rewritten as combination of #conv+#border ?
+[ ] #store: option zero (?)
+[ ] #import~, #export~
+[ ] #fold, #scan: option reverse (right-to-left)
+[ ] #join: option swap
+[ ] #matrix_inverse, #matrix_solve
+[ ] #timeline (or rtmetro): sequencing of events from grid
+[ ] #replace_if, #random_select, #markov_chain, #sort, #slice, #splice
+[ ] #polygon_perimeter, #polygon_area, #draw_polygon smoothly
+[ ] fuzzy #store (interpolate)
+[ ] write a complete benchmark script
+[ ] spatial biquads (ask Tom)
+[ ] string operations to compensate for the feebleness of PD in that area.
+ this includes [#sprintf].
+--- see also APL/J/NArray/PDL/Aplus/Yorick/IPOW reference
+
+Effects
+[ ] #mosaic
+[ ] #gaussian_blur, #sobel, #pixelize, #despeckle (median)
+[ ] #dither, #draw_lines, #draw_points, #fire, #queue
+[ ] #chroma_key: i0=RGBpicture i1=RGBcolor i2=tolerance o0=RGBApicture
+ with fuzzy flag; (don't call it #chroma_key though)
+ maybe #mask...
+[ ] turtle (logo style)
+[ ] effectv
+[ ] create abstractions for usage patterns (eg: like #remap_image)
+[ ] see gimp for ideas
+[ ] kaleidoscopes
+[ ] bilinear interpolation a+(b-a)*x+(c-a)*y+(a-b-c+d)*x*y (#scale_by smoothly?)
+[ ] #scale_by/#downscale_by fractional values
+[ ] bicubic interpolation
+[ ] multilinear interpolation (n-dimensional?)
+[ ] #daltonism
+[ ] #perlin ?
+[ ] #moment could support more than 2 dimensions
+
+#<vektor> told me to:
+# RGBtoYUV : @fobjects = ["#inner (3 3 # 66 -38 112 128 -74 -94 25 112 -18)","@ >> 8","@ + (16 128 128)"]
+# YUVtoRGB : @fobjects = ["@ - (16 128 128)",#inner (3 3 # 298 298 298 0 -100 516 409 -208 0)","@ >> 8"]
+
+Input/Output
+[ ] a #store that is persistent (saved in .pd) ?
+[ ] Grid: support storage in all six types
+[ ] Grid: bpv 1,2,4 uint
+[ ] Grid: text version of the format
+[ ] Gimp, GStreamer, ffmpeg, xine, mplayer, PDP, OSC
+[ ] get subtitling of tv channels
+[ ] add messages "load", "save" as open,bang,close combos. (?)
+[ ] x11,sdl,aalib: use buffering to synchronise frames at a constant rate.
+[ ] x11: sync with the actual vsync of the monitor
+[ ] x11: double buffering using a Pixmap remote-object
+[ ] [serial_port]
+[ ] support for audio in the mpeg streams
+[ ] synchronized audio with the video when using mpeg1 & 2
+[ ] full screen mode (without the menu bars or frames)
+[ ] support for audio in cameras / videodev ... see field vcaps.audios
+
+Format
+[ ] remaining number type support in formats
+[ ] fork: pseudoformat for launching format handler as separate process
+[ ] put_at/reassign in x11/sdl/quartz
+[ ] Generic SHM/MMAP Drivers
+[ ] "open grid pipe" and such.
+[ ] multi: multi-file (by glob pattern, e.g.: foo*.ppm)
+[ ] AVI
+[ ] format grid: "headerless until 10" (text files)
+
+User Interface
+[ ] color picker
+[ ] #edit, grid edition dialog, etc.
+[ ] vector slider (n parallel sliders in one, Dim(n))
+[ ] 2d slider
+[ ] radial slider (angle chooser)
+[ ] drag-and-drop palette of object construction
+[ ] object construction menu specialized for each class (generated from class reflection/metadata)
+
+Extra/Examples/Etc
+[ ] .pd: read; write better
+[ ] examples/generique.pd
+[ ] add examples from the workshop, etc
+
+<matju> alx:
+le tab completion ne donnerait pas seulement les noms possibles pour le
+prochain argument dans le objectbox; il donnerait aussi une description de
+l'argument (surtout dans le cas où l'argument a beaucoup de valeurs
+possibles). je pense que le help de Pd est une bonne idée (le concept hands-on)
+mais ça pourrait aller plus loin. j'ai pensé intégrer le manuel de référence de
+gridflow directement dans le programme, disponible au runtime, dans l'éventualité
+d'un GUI qui saurait en tirer avantage.
+
+<alx1> matju: détecter les formes; détecter les couleurs; support mpeg4; hotspots
+
+ClaudiusMaximus reports that allocating a 197M grid causes a crash (turns out C++
+throws exception, can't allocate, signal ABRT)
+
+ClaudiusMaximus says: I want to be able to send output from Pd+Gridflow to a video4linux
+loopback device so that other v4l programs can access the stream.
+I found the video loopback device here: http://motion.sourceforge.net/vloopback/
+
+<alx2>
+iSight on linux : http://episteme.arstechnica.com/6/ubb.x?a=tpc&s=50009562&f=8300945231&m=40110681
+needs something called 'coriander'. the person who got it working mentions libdc1394.
+http://www.tele.ucl.ac.be/PEOPLE/DOUXCHAMPS/ieee1394/cameras/index.html:
+I learn that the iSight is compliant with version 1.30 of IIDC.
+the docs for coriander mention that the author needed to create a major and minor device for the camera.
+retyping (damn pdf's) -> there are two devices to create: raw1394 and video1394
+raw1394 has major 171 and minor 0 while video1394 had major 171 and minor 16
+any useful info?
+having a camera like the iSight supported could be fantastic for video capture/detection on a laptop. Not to mention that the bttv cards are getting harder to locate
+
+-mfpmath=sse2
+
+remember to check for volatile VALUEs if GC problems ever occur
+
+Tom Schouten wrote: "
+added demo/rawvideo.pf and some support scripts in bin/pf-rawvideo.*
+this is an example on how to use external programs for raw video input.
+rationale:
+mplayer is a very nice piece of software supporting virtually any input
+format/codec. since i'm not planning to waste time on integrating more
+input codecs in pf, the best alternative is to have mplayer (actually
+mencoder) or ffmpeg as a subprocess.
+the same will be done for recording later.
+"
+
+very old bookmarks:
+ http://pdl.perl.org/
+ http://www.opendragon.com/Pages/MaxObjects.shtml (not responding)
+ gstreamer
+ Arts Builder
+ http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/rbf/HIPR2/wksheets.htm
+ http://freej.dyne.org/
+
+FObject.subclass("rubyarray",2,2) {
+ def initialize() @a=[]; @i=0; end
+ def _0_get(s=nil)
+ case s
+ when :size; send_out 1,:size,@a.size
+ when nil; _0_get :size
+ end
+ end
+ def _0_clear; @a.clear end
+ def _0_float i; @i=i; send_out 0, *@a[@i] if @a[@i]!=nil; end
+ def _1_list(*l) @a[@i]=l; end
+ def _0_save(filename,format=nil)
+ f=File.open(filename.to_s,"w")
+ if format then @a.each {|x| f.puts(format.to_s % x) }
+ else @a.each {|x| f.puts(x.join(",")) }
+ end
+ f.close
+ end
+ def _0_load(filename)
+ f=File.open(filename.to_s,"r")
+ @a.clear
+ f.each {|x| @a.push x.split(",").map {|y| Float(y) rescue y.intern }}
+ f.close
+ end
+}
+
+
+
+FObject.subclass("regsub",3,1) {
+ def initialize(from,to) _1_symbol(from); _2_symbol(to) end
+ def _0_symbol(s) send_out 0, :symbol, s.to_s.gsub(@from, @to).intern end
+ def _1_symbol(from) @from = Regexp.new(from.to_s.gsub(/`/,"\\")) end
+ def _2_symbol(to) @to = to.to_s.gsub(/`/,"\\") end
+ #doc:_0_symbol,"a string to transform"
+ #doc:_1_symbol,"a regexp pattern to be found inside of the string"
+ #doc:_2_symbol,"a replacement for the found pattern"
+ #doc_out:_0_symbol,"the transformed string"
+}
+
+FObject.subclass("memstat",1,1) {
+ def _0_bang
+ f = File.open("/proc/#{$$}/stat")
+ send_out 0, Float(f.gets.split(" ")[22]) / 1024.0
+ f.close
+ end
+ #doc:_0_bang,"lookup process stats for the currently running pd and figure out how much RAM it uses."
+ #doc_out:_0_float,"virtual size of RAM in kilobytes (includes swapped out and shared memory)"
+}
+
+FObject.subclass("rubysprintf",2,1) {
+ def initialize(*format) _1_list(format) end
+ def _0_list(*a) send_out 0, :symbol, (sprintf @format, *a).intern end
+ alias _0_float _0_list
+ alias _0_symbol _0_list
+ def _1_list(*format) @format = format.join(" ") end
+ alias _1_symbol _1_list
+}
+
+there are bugs with abstractions that use [route]->[list] instead of [route2] because they fail when $1="list".
+
+svn propset svn:mime-type text/pure-data *.pd
+
+Benchmarks on a Pentium M 1733 (with #out x11):
+(fps) 0.9.0 0.9.3 0.9.4
+waves.pd rain 41.1 49.5 50.5
+game_of_life.pd 162 183 188
+sand.pd 18.7 20.5 20.1
+cellular_1d.pd 115 130.1 130
+wave_1d.pd 63.0 81.7 81.7
+
+Benchmarks on a Pentium M 1733 (without window):
+(fps) 0.9.0 0.9.3 0.9.4
+waves.pd rain 50.1 63.0
+game_of_life.pd 397 507
+sand.pd 27 30
+cellular_1d.pd 475 730
+wave_1d.pd 107 173
+
+
+